Back to Blog

RentalWriteOff vs. CostSegSmart: Residential Cost Segregation Compared

Nov 2026 • 5 min read

By the RentalWriteOff editorial team · Reviewed against IRS guidance · Last reviewed 2026-11-20

Quick Summary

RentalWriteOff vs. CostSegSmart for residential rentals: flat $899 vs. price scaled to purchase price, completed Form 3115, who signs the report, evidence, and audit support.

Tax law changes over time. RentalWriteOff provides bonus depreciation applicability analysis in every report.

RentalWriteOff and CostSegSmart both prepare remote, done-for-you cost segregation studies with fast turnaround. The differences that matter for a residential rental are what the price includes, who signs the report, and what a look-back study costs once Form 3115 is done. This page compares the two on each, using RentalWriteOff's terms and CostSegSmart's own published pages, reviewed November 20, 2026.

Side by side

RentalWriteOff CostSegSmart
Method Engineering-based approach aligned with the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide Engineering-based studies, per their site
Residential price $899 flat, whatever the purchase price Scaled to purchase price: $495 at $150,000, $895 at $500,000, $995 at $850,000, $1,995 at $2.5 million
Form 3115 for look-back studies Completed form, Section 481(a) calculation, and supporting statements included 481(a) schedules and workpapers included; form preparation is a paid add-on, price not published
Who signs the report Tyler Nix signs every report: degree in construction engineering, more than 1,000 cost segregation studies reviewed Signer not named; their FAQ states standard studies are not signed by a licensed engineer, with engineer sign-off available as an add-on
Review before delivery Same engineering-based analysis and consistency checks on every study, then team review and signature Every paid report is quality-checked, per their site
Property evidence Proof image attached to every classified component; on-site visit available as an option Remote from documents and public records; residential site visit $595
Typical turnaround 2 business days 1–2 business days; 24-hour rush $495
Audit support Written responses on methodology and classifications, for the life of the study Written support for the life of the study, per their site

What a look-back study costs, completed

Most owners who find cost segregation after the first year need a look-back study, and a look-back is only finished when Form 3115 is prepared. RentalWriteOff includes the completed form in the $899 price. At CostSegSmart, the study fee covers the 481(a) schedules and workpapers, and preparing the form itself is a separate charge.

Single-family rental purchase price RentalWriteOff, completed look-back CostSegSmart, study fee
$500,000$899$895, plus Form 3115 preparation
$850,000$899$995, plus Form 3115 preparation
$2,500,000$899$1,995, plus Form 3115 preparation

For a current-year study on a property bought for around $150,000, CostSegSmart's published fee is lower. From about $500,000 up, and on any look-back study, RentalWriteOff's flat price covers more for the same or less.

A named signer on every report

When a CPA or an examiner reads a study, the first question is who stands behind it. Every RentalWriteOff report is checked by the review team and signed by Tyler Nix, who holds a degree in construction engineering and has reviewed more than 1,000 cost segregation studies. His name is on the document your CPA receives, on every study, at the standard price.

Evidence your CPA can check

Every component a RentalWriteOff study classifies carries a proof image attached to that line in the report, so your CPA can see what was classified and why. Every study uses an engineering-based approach aligned with the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide and runs through the same checks, so the result does not depend on who is assigned to the file. An on-site visit is available as an option for owners who want one.

Audit support

Both companies include written audit support for the life of the study. At RentalWriteOff that covers supporting documentation, written responses to the taxing authority, and a written explanation of the classifications and methodology. The Terms set out what it covers.

Frequently asked questions

Is RentalWriteOff or CostSegSmart better for a residential rental?

For a look-back study, or a property bought for about $500,000 or more, RentalWriteOff includes more at the same or lower price: the completed Form 3115, a named signer with a construction engineering degree, and photo evidence on every classified component, all at $899 flat. CostSegSmart's published fee is lower on inexpensive properties for current-year studies.

Does CostSegSmart include Form 3115?

CostSegSmart includes the Section 481(a) schedules and workpapers with look-back studies and lists Form 3115 preparation as a paid add-on; its pages did not publish that price on November 20, 2026. RentalWriteOff includes the completed Form 3115 for eligible look-back studies in its $899 standard residential price.

Who signs a RentalWriteOff report?

Tyler Nix signs every RentalWriteOff report after the review team checks it. Tyler holds a degree in construction engineering and has reviewed more than 1,000 cost segregation studies.


See your projected first-year deductions in about a minute with the instant estimate, or start your study. For all six providers side by side, see the best cost segregation companies for rental properties.

Disclaimer: RentalWriteOff provides cost segregation studies using an engineering-based approach and prepares Form 3115 for eligible look-back studies. We do not provide tax, legal, or accounting advice or file tax returns. Consult a qualified tax professional for advice specific to your situation.

See what your rental could save you

Enter your property address and get a projected first-year write-off in about a minute. Free, no signup.

$899 flat fee · 2 business days · audit support included